Margot Robbie is an Australian actress who has risen to fame in recent years, starring in major blockbuster films like The Wolf of Wall Street, Suicide Squad, and Birds of Prey.
While Robbie is undoubtedly talented and has many fans, she has also faced some backlash and criticism from certain groups over the course of her career.
In this article, we’ll explore some of the main reasons why Margot Robbie has detractors and why she rubs some people the wrong way.
Her Rapid Rise to Fame
One of the primary reasons why Margot Robbie has haters is that her rise to stardom in Hollywood felt unusually abrupt for some. She went from being a relatively unknown Australian actress to headlining major studio films almost overnight.
Robbie had her breakthrough role in Martin Scorsese’s The Wolf of Wall Street in 2013, starring alongside Leonardo DiCaprio. Prior to that, she was mainly known for starring on the Australian soap opera Neighbours. After Wolf of Wall Street, Robbie started landing many coveted, high-profile roles in various blockbuster franchises.
To some, Robbie’s meteoric rise seemed undeserved or premature. They felt she didn’t “pay her dues” or work her way up gradually in the usual fashion. This resentment over her rapid ascent led to increased scrutiny and criticism of her acting skills and talent.
Perception of Favoritism or Special Treatment
Related to the swiftness of Robbie’s rise to fame is the perception among some that she has been the beneficiary of favoritism or special treatment in Hollywood.
Various rumors have suggested that she was helped by powerful friends or that she received roles due to her looks or supposed romantic relationships rather than her acting ability alone.
Whether valid or not, these rumors have contributed to a narrative that Robbie didn’t completely earn her success on her own merits. For those already inclined to dislike her, it feeds into the perception that she is overrated or undeserving of being catapulted to A-list status so quickly.
Her Association with Harley Quinn
Another source of annoyance or criticism towards Margot Robbie stems from her portrayal of popular DC villain Harley Quinn. Robbie has played Harley in multiple films now, including Suicide Squad and Birds of Prey.
For some comic book fans and moviegoers, Robbie’s version of Harley just doesn’t live up to the original character. Her acting choices and overall interpretation of the role don’t align with what certain fans envisioned for this beloved comic character.
There is also a segment of male comic book fans who simply dislike the idea of a beautiful, blonde actress portraying their favorite psycho villainess. To them, Robbie misses the mark and can’t capture Harley Quinn’s true manic, unstable essence.
Claims She’s Overhyped or Overrated
As Margot Robbie started landing big roles intended to make her a major star, some film fans and critics began pushing back by claiming she is overhyped or overrated.
In their view, she is not actually worthy of being treated like an A-list talent or put on the level of more seasoned, respected actresses. Detractors argue she has been given too much acclaim and status before proving herself as a truly skilled performer.
There are complaints that the media focuses too much attention on her looks and off-screen life rather than judging her strictly on acting ability. The perception persists among naysayers that she is a product of media hype who gets roles based on her beauty rather than pure acting chops.
Perceived Lack of Range or Versatility
Another common criticism of Margot Robbie is that she lacks range as an actress or has yet to show versatility in her roles. So far, she has starred primarily in blockbuster films centered around action, crime, or sex appeal.
Some feel that Robbie keeps getting cast in similar archetypes – like the femme fatale or damaged beauty – and therefore hasn’t demonstrated the acting depth of her more acclaimed peers.
There is a sense that she needs to break out of her mold and do an indie character drama or totally transform herself for a role in order to prove her skills and win over more skeptics.
Controversies or Scandals During Her Career
Like many celebrities, Margot Robbie has faced occasional controversies or minor scandals during her time in the public eye. While Robbie herself is typically not directly responsible, these incidents still shape her public image and cause some to think negatively of her.
For example, there was criticism of her frequent nudity or controversial sex scenes in The Wolf of Wall Street, which some saw as gratuitous. More recently, Robbie’s personal life has been heavily scrutinized, including speculation about her relationships with co-stars and attention on her divorce.
While minor in the grand scheme, these tabloid-fueling controversies reinforce any preexisting negativity people may harbor towards Robbie and her perceived undeserved status.
Her Association with Controversial Directors/Actors
In addition to starring in films with controversial subject matter, Margot Robbie has frequently worked with directors and co-stars who themselves have checkered reputations.
Her breakout role was in a Martin Scorsese film, collaborating closely with Leonardo DiCaprio. Both men have been surrounded by scandal or allegations of misogynistic behavior.
Robbie’s association with filmmakers and actors who have their own detractors leads some to look at her warily as well, regardless of whether she bears any personal responsibility. It’s a case of “guilt by association” that can unconsciously color people’s opinions of her.
Concerns Over Whitewashing in Some Roles
While still in the early stages of her career, Margot Robbie has faced some backlash for taking roles that were originally non-white characters in source material. For instance, her role as Jane Porter in The Legend of Tarzan spawned accusations of whitewashing a character who was black in the original novels.
Similarly, her casting as Tonya Harding in the biopic I, Tonya was critiqued by those who felt a white actress shouldn’t portray the first working-class figure skater to achieve prominence. Though unintentional, taking these roles added more fuel to the claims that Robbie benefits from favoritism in Hollywood.
Her Characters Lack Depth or Nuance
On a performance level, Margot Robbie is sometimes criticized for portraying characters who are beautiful but ultimately two-dimensional or lacking in nuance. For instance, her version of Harley Quinn leans heavily into sex appeal without showcasing the character’s full, flawed humanity.
Across her films, critics argue that Robbie excels at playing the bombshell love interest but falls short when trying to deliver more layered, complex characters. Detractors say she needs stronger acting chops in order to imbue her roles with more emotional depth and gravitas beyond their surface-level appeal.
In summary, Margot Robbie elicits dislike from some audiences for a variety of reasons. Her unusually rapid rise paired with a perceived lack of versatility makes her an easy target for claims of being overrated.
Her association with controversial subject matter and collaborators also stokes criticism from certain circles. While Robbie undoubtedly has talent, she still faces an uphill battle to prove herself against those predisposed to view her success as undeserved.
With the right roles that showcase greater range, she may eventually change minds. For now, her career remains divisive.
Why Do Some Dislike Margot Robbie’s Portrayal of Harley Quinn?
Margot Robbie’s portrayal of popular DC villain Harley Quinn has proven controversial among certain subsets of fans and moviegoers. Here are some of the main reasons why her version of Harley Quinn rubs some viewers the wrong way:
Overly Sexualized Depiction
One common complaint is that Robbie’s Harley Quinn is too sexualized and overly focused on showcasing Robbie’s beauty.
Her costume and on-screen mannerisms are designed to objectify her in the eyes of some critics. This overt sex appeal detracts from Harley’s insane, deadly nature.
Lacks Genuine Mania or Unpredictability
Relatedly, some argue Robbie fails to capture Harley’s genuine mania, unpredictability, and underlying psyche. Her performance is too sane, stable, and lacking in the chaotic energy that should define the Joker’s unhinged partner-in-crime.
Departs Too Much from Original Characterizations
Comic book purists take issue with the excessive liberties Robbie and the filmmakers have taken in reimagining Harley’s backstory, appearance, and overall vibe. To them, she is unrecognizable next to the original Harley Quinn from Batman animated shows and comics.
Reliance on Sex Appeal Over Acting Range
Critics of Robbie’s portrayal argue she was miscast due to her looks and relies too heavily on sex appeal while lacking real acting chops to bring out Harley’s complexities. They believe the role demands a performer who better embodies Harley’s inherent weirdness.
Lacks Genuine Chemistry with Jared Leto’s Joker
For some viewers, the on-screen relationship between Robbie’s Harley Quinn and Jared Leto’s Joker feels forced or falls flat. Their interactions lack a sinister, twisted energy that should exist between these two connection characters.
Isn’t Given Room to Showcase Range
Defenders argue the shallow writing and minimal screen time for Harley in Suicide Squad limit Robbie’s ability to create a well-rounded portrayal. With more room to grow in future films, she may better demonstrate her acting abilities.
Doesn’t Sync With Certain Fans’ Vision of Character
No portrayal will satisfy all fans, as everyone has their own vision of iconic characters. For some Harley Quinn purists, Robbie simply does not align with their personal image of how the character looks, acts, and feels on screen.
What are Margot Robbie’s Strengths and Weaknesses as an Actress?
- Natural charisma and likability on screen
- Capable of playing tough, fiercely independent women
- Talented at portraying unhinged but endearing characters
- Extremely beautiful and photogenic
- Solid comedic timing and instincts
- Fearless in taking on challenging roles
- Throws herself completely into her roles
- Has yet to showcase truly impressive acting range
- Tends to play similar archetypes (bombshell, femme fatale, etc)
- Hasn’t carried a film solely on her acting merits
- Characters sometimes lack nuance or complexity
- Can come across as miscast in certain roles
- American accent is not always convincing
- Still early in her career trajectory
What Roles Could Allow Margot Robbie to Showcase More Versatility?
Here are some types of film roles that could give Margot Robbie the opportunity to demonstrate more versatility and depth as an actress:
- A period drama – This would allow Robbie to transform into a different era and drop modern mannerisms.
- A biopic about a real-life individual – Robbie could immerse herself in embodying the look, voice, and spirit of a historical figure.
- An indie character study – With the right script and director, Robbie could sink her teeth into a messy, flawed, complex character.
- A film requiring an extreme physical transformation – Whether gaining/losing significant weight or adopting a disability, this would show Robbie’s commitment.
- A psycho-thriller – This genre would enable Robbie to show off her ability to play disturbed, unhinged characters.
- A tragic drama – Robbie can exhibit emotional range by tackling a weighty film dealing with grief and trauma.
- A nonlinear/experimental film – Robbie could work with unconventional directors to test herself in innovative genres and formats.
- A musical or dance film – This would permit Robbie to showcase talents beyond pure acting, like singing, dancing or playing instruments.
- A foreign/non-English speaking role – Robbie speaking another language would immediately set apart from previous roles.
In closing, Margot Robbie is a polarizing Hollywood figure who elicits strong reactions from both fans and detractors. Her rapid ascent and perceived favoritism breeds resentment from some quarters.
However, she has undoubtedly shown talent that could grow with more versatile roles. Robbie faces ongoing scrutiny but seems determined to forge her own path on her own terms.
If she continues taking risks and defying expectations, Robbie may eventually turn most critics into admirers. Only time will tell whether she can transcend the labels of bombshell and blockbuster star to become a truly respected acting powerhouse.
Frequently Asked Questions About Margot Robbie
Why do some people think Margot Robbie is overrated?
Some believe Margot Robbie is overrated because she became a major Hollywood star very quickly without paying her dues. There is a perception that she gets roles due to looks rather than superior acting ability. Her range has also been questioned.
What was Margot Robbie’s breakout role?
Margot Robbie’s breakout role was as Naomi Lapaglia in The Wolf of Wall Street (2013). Her memorable performance opposite Leonardo DiCaprio led to Robbie being cast in various major blockbuster films.
What are Margot Robbie’s most famous roles?
Robbie’s most famous roles include:
- Harley Quinn in Suicide Squad and Birds of Prey
- Jane in The Legend of Tarzan
- Tonya Harding in I, Tonya
- Sharon Tate in Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
- Naomi Lapaglia in The Wolf of Wall Street
Has Margot Robbie won any major acting awards?
Margot Robbie has been nominated for two Academy Awards for Best Actress in a Supporting Role for Bombshell (2019) and Best Actress for I, Tonya (2017). She has not yet won an Oscar but has won some critics association awards.
What upcoming projects does Margot Robbie have?
Upcoming films starring Margot Robbie include Babylon with Brad Pitt, Asteroid City directed by Wes Anderson, and Barbie where she will play the famous doll. Robbie also has a Barbie film in development through her production company.
Why do some comic fans dislike Robbie’s Harley Quinn?
Some comic book fans take issue with Margot Robbie’s Harley Quinn because her portrayal is overly sexualized, departs too much from original versions, and lacks the true manic energy that defines the character.
Who does Margot Robbie frequently collaborate with?
Robbie often collaborates with directors Martin Scorsese and Quentin Tarantino. She frequently co-stars with actors like Will Smith, Leonardo DiCaprio, and Brad Pitt. Robbie is also producing some upcoming films through her LuckyChap production company.
What is Margot Robbie’s net worth?
According to multiple reports, Margot Robbie’s current net worth is estimated to be around $16 million. However, she earned $10 million alone for Birds of Prey, so her net worth is likely higher and rising quickly given her A-list status.
Is Margot Robbie married?
Margot Robbie is married to British film producer Tom Ackerley. They wed in 2016 after meeting on the set of Suite Française in 2014, which Ackerley produced. In 2019, Robbie and Ackerley launched a production company called LuckyChap Entertainment.
What is Margot Robbie’s background?
Margot Robbie is Australian and grew up on the Gold Coast. She began acting professionally in 2007 on the TV show Neighbours. After moving to the U.S. in 2011, Robbie had small roles before her breakthrough in The Wolf of Wall Street.