Mariah Carey is one of the most successful and best-selling musical artists of all time. With over 200 million records sold worldwide, she holds the record for the most number-one singles by a solo artist. However, despite her immense success and talent, Mariah Carey has also attracted a fair share of haters over the years. Here are some of the main reasons why people dislike Mariah Carey:
Her Diva Reputation
One of the most common reasons cited for disliking Mariah is her alleged diva behavior and demanding attitude. Stories of her outrageous rider requests, such as requiring 20 white kittens and 100 doves in her dressing room, have added to her reputation as a diva. There have also been reports of her being hours late for interviews, photoshoots, and even concerts.
Many feel her privileged upbringing and immense success has made her act entitled and difficult to work with. Her over-the-top demands and lateness do not sit well with people who see it as unprofessional and disrespectful. Her reputation as a diva has turned off many people over the years.
Her Vocal Decline
During her prime in the 1990s, Mariah was renowned for her incredible 5-octave vocal range and her signature whistling register. However, in recent years, her voice has noticeably declined due to age and possibly overuse. She has struggled to hit the high notes that she once effortlessly reached.
Fans who grew up listening to her flawless vocals have been disappointed by her subpar live performances. The contrast between her prime vocal abilities and her strained singing now has caused many longtime fans to lose respect for her. They feel she should adapt her songs to fit her current range rather thancontinue trying to sing them exactly as before.
Her Attention-Seeking Antics
Throughout her career, Mariah has pulled some over-the-top stunts that many deem as attention-seeking antics to stay relevant. This includes flashing her cleavage at every opportunity, wearing outrageous outfits, and even stripping down to a bodysuit during a live performance.
While her fans find it entertaining, others see it as desperate cries for attention from an aging star. Her sexualized persona and flashy style are viewed by some as Mariah simply trying too hard to be hot and current. Many feel she should act more maturely and classily at this stage of her career.
Her Massive Ego
Mariah is often accused of having an enormous ego and an overinflated sense of self-importance. She has claimed she’s the “greatest singer alive” and compared her voice to celebrated opera singer Maria Callas. Her backstage demands to only be photographed on the left side of her face have also been labeled as egomaniacal.
Additionally, her public comments about other artists like Jennifer Lopez, Christina Aguilera, and Eminem have demonstrated hubris in the eyes of her detractors. Her tendency to make everything about herself and her achievements rubs people the wrong way. To many, she comes across as a narcissist who believes her own hype.
Her Numerous Romances
As a tabloid fixture for decades, Mariah’s personal life has also contributed to her haters. She has been married twice and has had several high-profile boyfriends over the years, including Derek Jeter and Nick Cannon.
The frequent change of partners, along with rumors of cheating and heartbreak, have given Mariah a reputation as being unstable and overly-focused on men. Her overly sexual lyrics and skimpy outfits feed into this image for many. They see her as more obsessed with love and lust than making meaningful music.
Her Holiday Domination
While beloved by many, Mariah’s holiday classic “All I Want For Christmas Is You” has also spawned resentment from some over the years. Rising to #1 on the charts every December, her song and massive marketing campaign are accused of sucking all the air out of the holiday music space.
Some feel she exploits her holiday hit song as a cash cow year after year. The omnipresence of this decades-old song during the holidays has caused major Mariah fatigue for many who want more variety in holiday music. They are tired of her dominating the entire Christmas season every single year.
Her Reliance on Sex Appeal
Throughout her career, Mariah has faced criticism for relying heavily on her sex appeal versus her vocal talent. As she has aged, her outfits have become skimpier while her vocals have declined.
Many accuse her of using her body and sexuality to distract from her diminishing singing abilities. Her critics feel she opts for shock value and thirst traps over quality music lately. They take issue with her hypersexualized persona and believe she trades more on her looks now versus her talent.
Her Frequently Cancelled Performances
In recent years, Mariah has faced backlash for cancelling or postponing a significant number of her concerts and public appearances. Her excuses range from illness to technical difficulties, but many feel they are signs of her waning passion for performing.
Disappointed fans who purchased expensive tickets have slammed her work ethic and commitment to her shows. The constant cancelled gigs with vague explanations have angered both fans and promoters alike. Many now see her as lazy, undependable, and disrespectful towards audiences.
Her 2001 Glitter Breakdown
Mariah’s much-publicized emotional breakdown in 2001 damaged her reputation in the eyes of the public. Triggered by the critical and commercial failure of her film Glitter, she exhibited erratic behavior that was captured extensively by the media. Her hospitalization for exhaustion demonstrated a troubled side to the previously unflappable star.
While likely stemming from untreated bipolar disorder, her very public unraveling made Mariah seem unstable, ungrateful for her success, and unable to handle challenges. She has worked hard to rehabilitate her image since, but some still view her as someone who cracked under pressure at the first sign of failure. They feel it exposed her as self-absorbed and ill-equipped to handle anything less than superstardom.
Her Seriousness and Lack of Fun
In contrast to fellow pop divas like Beyonce and Lady Gaga, Mariah is frequently criticized for lacking a fun, lighthearted side these days. Where other stars have silly, humorous public personas, Mariah is seen as taking herself way too seriously.
Aside from her holiday hit, she has discarded the campy, cheerful image of her early career for one that is hyper-focused on her vocals and sex appeal. Her interviews often come across as haughty instead of down-to-earth. While some stars soften with age, Mariah seems to have become more self-important and humorless over the years in the public eye.
Mariah Carey’s stratospheric career has made her one of the most famous singers in the world. However, with great fame comes greater scrutiny and criticism. Her alleged diva antics, declining voice, attention-seeking behavior, massive ego, troubled love life, oversaturation, and breakdown have all fueled animosity towards the superstar singer over her decades in the spotlight.
While she still has a passionate fanbase who adore her smash hits and vocal talents, Mariah has become a polarizing pop culture figure. Her critics feel she is an over-the-hill prima donna trading more on her celebrity than her musical abilities at this point. However, constant sold-out tours and her record-breaking 19 #1 hits prove Mariah still has an audience who love her. She has managed to thrive despite the vitriol thrown her way by some detractors.
No matter how you feel about Mariah Carey, there is no denying she made an indelible mark on pop music. The self-proclaimed “songbird supreme” has given the world some of the most popular and enduring hits ever. Even without her whistle register and hand gestures, Mariah remains one of music’s most iconic divas.
Frequently Asked Questions about Why People Dislike Mariah Carey
Why is Mariah Carey considered a diva?
Mariah is seen as a diva due to stories of her outrageous demands like requiring 20 white kittens in her dressing room. She also has a reputation for being late to events, acting difficult, and making everything about her and her needs ahead of others.
How has Mariah Carey’s voice changed over the years?
In her early career, Mariah was known for her incredible 5-octave range and use of her whistle register. However, in recent years, her voice has noticeably declined and she struggles to sing the high notes she once easily reached.
What attention-seeking antics has Mariah engaged in?
Mariah has pulled stunts like flashing cleavage, wearing outrageous outfits, and stripping during performances. These antics are viewed by some as desperate cries for attention from an aging performer.
What comments has Mariah made to demonstrate her ego?
She has claimed to be the “greatest singer alive” and compared herself to opera legend Maria Callas. She has also made arrogant comments about other artists like Jennifer Lopez.
How does Mariah exploit her song “All I Want for Christmas is You”?
Mariah heavily markets, promotes, and cashes in on this holiday hit each year. Some feel she saturates the season with this decades-old song and stifles any newer holiday music.
How has Mariah relied more on sex appeal as she’s aged?
As her voice has declined, Mariah wears increasingly skimpy outfits and uses sexuality to distract from weaker vocals. Critics feel she opts for shock value and thirst traps over quality music.
What incidents have fueled the perception that Mariah can’t handle challenges?
Her 2001 breakdown from exhaustion after her film Glitter flopped made her seem unable to cope with failure. Cancelled concerts since then also make her seem uncommitted.
How has Mariah’s public persona changed over the years?
The lighthearted, bubbly image she had early on has given way to one where she is viewed as humorless, self-important, and intensely serious.