Diane Keaton is an Oscar-winning actress who came to fame in the 1970s for her collaborations with director Woody Allen in films like Annie Hall and Manhattan.
While beloved by many, Keaton has also been criticized and even hated by some over the years. Here’s an in-depth look at some of the possible reasons why Diane Keaton rubs certain people the wrong way.
Does Diane Keaton’s Acting Style Annoy Some People?
One of the most commonly cited reasons for disliking Keaton is her distinct acting style. Keaton has a tendency to play quirky, neurotic characters who stammer, ramble, and act awkwardly in social situations.
Some find this acting style charming and endearing. For others, it comes across as grating, over the top, and affected. Keaton’s characters often seem anxious, high strung, and fidgety in a way some viewers find grating.
The stuttering, fast talking, and excessive gesturing can strike some as contrived and mannered rather than naturalistic. Even in dramatic roles, Keaton frequently employs these nervous tics and idiosyncrasies in a way that rubs certain audience members the wrong way.
Her Signature Acting Style Was Solidified in Woody Allen Films
Keaton’s idiosyncratic acting style was crystallized and amplified in the films she made with Woody Allen in the 1970s, particularly Annie Hall. Her Academy Award winning performance as the quintessential neurotic New Yorker cemented this stuttering, awkward persona as Keaton’s signature.
Some criticize her later performances as Annie Hall knockoffs, calling her characters one-note and her acting choices overdone self-parody. They see her as leaning too heavily on the same bag of Allen-esque ticks and mannerisms rather than disappearing into diverse roles.
Keaton’s Habit of “Playing Herself” Can Feel Self-Indulgent
Related to complaints about Keaton repeating the same acting style is the criticism she essentially just “plays herself” in every role. Detractors feel she indulges her own personality quirks and preoccupations rather than transforming into her characters.
Even in later, more dramatic films like Marvin’s Room, Keaton has been accused of essentially playing a version of her familiar neurotic persona rather than showing range. While stars like Meryl Streep disappear into their roles, some argue Keaton just trots out “Diane Keaton” again and again in a self-indulgent way.
Do Keaton’s Real-Life Persona and Opinions Irk Some Fans?
Beyond her acting style, Keaton’s off-screen persona and opinions have also elicited criticism and hatred from certain circles over the years. Specifically, some are put off by what they perceive as:
Her Pretentious Affectations and Sense of Superiority
Keaton has a reputation for acting intellectually and artistically superior to Hollywood fare. Her lofty comments about her creative ambitions have struck some as pretentious.
She is also known for eccentric behavior like wearing gloves and hats year-round. Some find her avant garde, artsy affectations to be elitist or hollow self-aggrandizement.
Her Vocal Political Stands and Feminist Viewpoints
Never one to shy away from political commentary, Keaton has been very outspoken over the years on controversial issues like feminism and politics.
She’s come under fire for smugly criticizing certain politicians and for seeming to hold herself up as a paragon of sophisticated liberal values. This has predictably rubbed more conservative fans the wrong way.
Her Caginess and Reluctance to Discuss Her Private Life
For someone who gives interviews and writes memoirs, Keaton remains remarkably cryptic about certain aspects of her life.
She rarely discusses topics like romantic relationships or even her reported adopting two children later in life. Some find her evasiveness in interviews to be self-important and distracting.
Has Backlash Against Her Woody Allen Collaborations Impacted Her Reputation?
Finally, Keaton’s frequent collaborations with controversial director Woody Allen have made her a target of criticism, especially in recent years. The backlash against Allen in the wake of abuse allegations has cast a shadow over Keaton due to her close ties to the director.
Starring in Allen’s Films Has Led to Guilt By Association For Some
While Keaton has not been directly implicated in any of the accusations against Allen, the fact that he gave her some of her most famous roles has linked her reputation to his misconduct in the minds of some. She’s been criticized for not speaking out more forcefully against her former mentor.
Defending Allen Has Compounded Her Problems With His Critics
Not only has Keaton mostly avoided discussing the accusations against Allen, she’s occasionally made statements perceived as defending or excusing his alleged behavior. This has made her an even bigger target of wrath from those who believe Allen’s accusers.
She’s Been Lumped in With “Cancel Woody” Sentiments
Just as it took years for allegations against Allen to impact his reputation, Keaton managed to escape association with him for a long time. But as condemnation of Allen has ramped up in recent years, blowback has splashed onto Keaton for not adequately renouncing him and his films.
How Has Ageism Potentially Impacted Attitudes Towards Keaton?
On top of all these factors, some have suggested that simple ageism plays a role in the negative reactions Keaton elicits from certain corners. Some of the traits that people found charming in her youth come across to some as less appealing in an older woman.
Her Quirkiness Can Read as “Odd” or “Eccentric” Now
The kooky, idiosyncratic personality that made Keaton so likable in the 70s strikes some today as odd or eccentric in a woman in her mid-70s. The “absent-minded artist” routine doesn’t play as well when she’s not the young “Annie Hall” version of that archetype.
Her Rambling Interviews Can Seem Confused or Scattered
Similarly, the endearing way Keaton rambled and digressed in interviews decades ago can come across today as bewildering or ditzy. Instead of being seen as thoughtful and introspective, she’s accused by some of just being confused, long-winded and out of touch.
Her Clothing Choices Can Appear Dated or Even Childish
Keaton’s preference for gloves, hats, and menswear inspired fashion were once hailed as the height of quirky cool. But in an older woman, this consistent style can strike some observers as dowdy, dated or even unconsciously childish instead of stylish.
In the end, the criticisms and hatred directed at Diane Keaton likely stem from a mix of factors. Her unusual acting style and persona, divisive political stances, association with Woody Allen, and simple ageism all seem to play a role.
But while she’s certainly not universally beloved, Keaton remains an Oscar-winning Hollywood icon who created an enduring, indelible character in Annie Hall. The hatred she provokes from some likely says more about them than it does about this groundbreaking, quintessentially quirky star.
Frequently Asked Questions About Diane Keaton Hatred
Why do some people find Diane Keaton annoying?
Some find Keaton’s acting style in films like Annie Hall to be grating and affected, with too much stuttering, rambling, and eccentric tics. Her tendency to “play herself” in roles rather than transform is seen by critics as one-note self-parody.
What political views and opinions do people dislike her for?
Keaton has been outspoken on controversial issues like feminism and politics. Her liberal commentary and smugness towards certain conservative politicians has alienated some fans. She’s also been criticized for defending Woody Allen amidst abuse allegations.
How has ageism potentially contributed to Keaton backlash?
Keaton’s quirky mannerisms and rambling speech that seemed charming when she was younger now strike some as odd or ditzy for a woman in her 70s. Her eclectic fashion can also be seen as dated and eccentric rather than stylish now.
Why does Keaton’s association with Woody Allen hurt her reputation?
Collaborating with Allen has led to guilt by association as she’s been criticized for not disavowing him more amidst abuse allegations. Defending Allen has also made her a target of backlash from those who believe his accusers.
How has Keaton reacted to criticism and backlash over the years?
Keaton has largely shrugged off hatred and criticism, staying true to her acting style and bold opinions. She has occasionally defended herself but mostly focuses on her work rather than Internet commentary. Her individualism remains unchanged.
Does Keaton have many dedicated fans and supporters despite the hatred?
Absolutely. While controversial among some circles, Keaton maintains a sizable fanbase who grew up with her films and appreciate her unique talent and courage. Many find her quirks charming and her outspoken nature admirable.
What lasting legacy has Keaton left on Hollywood?
As an Oscar winner, prolific actress, and muse to Woody Allen, Keaton made an indelible mark on cinema with films like Annie Hall. She paved the way for eccentric female characters and created an iconic neurotic archetype. Her impact is undeniable.
How has Keaton responded to accusations of being self-indulgent?
Keaton has brushed off criticism that she just plays versions of herself, saying she pours her true self into roles because that’s her authentic acting style. She finds playing into her quirks and speech patterns organic, not self-indulgent.
Does Keaton have any notable upcoming projects?
Yes, Keaton continues working steadily, with upcoming roles in films like Mack & Rita with Elizabeth Lail and Dianne Wiest and the TV series The Staircase based on the true-crime docuseries. Fans can look forward to her signature style in these projects and more.